Screen Signals creator assessment

Is Robert Welsh appropriate for kids?

@robertwelsh · A parent-focused assessment based on a sample of recent and popular public long-form videos, not a review of every upload.

12 videos analyzed Last analyzed August 21, 2026View channel on YouTube
Scores by age

Age-specific assessment

Choose an age range.

ScreenSignals.ai
60of 100

Robert Welsh

For ages 8–10

Some concerns to review

The main things to review are mature and sensitive topics, and commercial pressure. Educational or thought-provoking material appeared more than once.

High confidence based on 12 videos reviewed
LanguageA few concerns79
Violence & intensityFew concerns100
Sexual or suggestive contentFew concerns100
Substances & risky behaviorFew concerns100
Harassment & role modelingFew concerns85
Fear & disturbing themesFew concerns97
Mature & sensitive topicsSome concerns56
Commercial pressureA few concerns76
Positive things we found
  • Educational or thought-provoking material appeared more than once.
  • Kindness, empathy, or supportive relationships appeared more than once.
  • Creativity, imagination, or constructive problem-solving appeared more than once.
Things a parent may want to know
  • Some makeup looks shown are gothic and artistic, which might be more suitable for older children or teens interested in creative makeup rather than young children.
  • The video includes promotional content and discount codes, which may influence purchasing behavior.
  • Some mild casual language including one mild expletive censored ('f*ck').
  • Mentions minor product issues like a brush needing cleaning or reshaping, but no serious concerns.
  • Contains mild language including a brief mild expletive.
Videos reviewed

A quick look at the videos

See the individual videos that shaped this assessment and the main points an adult parent may want to know.

recent · standard video78/100

The Chinese Beauty Takeover | Best C-beauty Makeup Brands Tested!!

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Some makeup looks shown are gothic and artistic, which might be more suitable for older children or teens interested in creative makeup rather than young children.
  • The video includes promotional content and discount codes, which may influence purchasing behavior.
  • Provides a detailed and enthusiastic review of C-beauty makeup products.
recent · standard video78/100

TESTING TATI'S BRUSHES.. 👀 | Details by Tati brush set review.

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Some mild casual language including one mild expletive censored ('f*ck').
  • Mentions minor product issues like a brush needing cleaning or reshaping, but no serious concerns.
  • Detailed and honest product review with personal experience.
recent · standard video78/100

ACNE HEALING CONCEALER? | Ranking new makeup releases!!

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Contains mild language including a brief mild expletive.
  • Includes commercial promotion and discount codes which may influence viewers.
  • Some product claims (e.g., acne healing concealer) are discussed with skepticism but no medical advice is given.
recent · standard video78/100

TESTING NEW MAKEUP RELEASES! | huda beauty, prada, benefit and more! keep, fix, dump!

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Contains promotional discount codes and affiliate links which may influence purchasing decisions.
  • Mentions personal phobia (butterflies) briefly but without distressing detail.
  • Some product descriptions include subjective opinions on scent and taste which might not appeal to all viewers.
recent · standard video81/100

MAKEUP Q&A

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Some casual mild language (e.g., a mild expletive) is used briefly at the start.
  • Mentions of Botox as a cosmetic procedure without detailed medical context.
  • References to personal experiences with sensitive topics like psoriasis and eczema, but handled sensitively.
popular · standard video91/100

YOU'RE TOO POOR TO LOOK GOOD!!! CHARLOTTE TILBURY SAYS!!

Score for ages 8–10 · Few concerns
  • Contains some strong opinions and criticism of specific brands and individuals.
  • Discusses industry competition and legal actions which may be complex for younger viewers.
  • Mentions copying and intellectual property issues that might require adult understanding.
popular · standard video43/100

This new Brand canceled themselves pre launch!

Score for ages 8–10 · Many concerns
  • Contains frequent strong language and insults directed at the brand owner and their behavior.
  • Includes criticism and negative judgments about the brand owner's professionalism and ethics.
  • Discusses the contentious topic of AI replacing human jobs, which may be sensitive for some viewers.
popular · standard video22/100

PATRICK TA STEALING AGAIN | Patrick Ta, Painted by Esther blush controversy

Score for ages 8–10 · Serious concerns
  • Contains some strong language and expressions of frustration that may be intense for younger viewers.
  • Discusses industry conflicts and accusations of appropriation which may be complex for children to understand.
  • Mentions illness and emotional distress of an artist, which could be sensitive content.
popular · standard video26/100

This 'Creator Academy' is Exploiting Aspiring Influencers

Score for ages 8–10 · Serious concerns
  • Contains strong criticism of a specific brand and its program, which may influence viewer perceptions.
  • Discusses industry practices that might be discouraging for new creators.
  • Mentions concepts like unpaid labor and restrictive contracts that could be complex for younger viewers.
popular · standard video78/100

TESTING OVERHYPED MAKEUP!! BRUTAL HONESTY!!

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • Contains promotional discount codes and product links, indicating commercial pressure.
  • Mentions minor cosmetic concerns like glitter in products, which may not suit all viewers.
  • Provides honest, personal reviews of multiple makeup products.
popular · standard video76/100

HUDA'S NEW FRAGRANCE IS FISH?? | The viral huda fragrance drama !!

Score for ages 8–10 · A few concerns
  • The video contains mild strong language (censored) used repeatedly in a casual rant style.
  • There is some mild criticism and personal commentary about other influencers and brands, which might be perceived as negative tone.
  • The video discusses a public controversy which might involve some social media drama context.
popular · standard video93/100

THE WORST PRODUCTS IVE TRIED | DONT BUY THESE!!

Score for ages 8–10 · Few concerns
  • Contains some mild negative language expressing disappointment and frustration with products.
  • Mentions strong fragrance in one product that might be unpleasant to sensitive viewers.
  • Includes some mild critique of influencer hype and marketing claims, which may be confusing for younger viewers.
Read this score correctly

A channel assessment is a starting point, not a guarantee.

The assessment evaluates observable patterns in the sampled videos. It does not cover private or deleted videos, comments, recommendations, livestream behavior, visual-only moments that cannot be reliably identified, or every upload.

Creator-controlled source material is treated only as evidence and cannot instruct or override the analysis. Pages are refreshed and may be unpublished when evidence becomes stale or unreliable.

See the complete sampling and scoring method